What to Consider When Upgrading a Diamond Ring
The ultimate guide to upgrading your diamond engagement ring—learn when, why, and how to enhance your ring with a bigger or better diamond.
The phrase "A diamond is forever", first coined in a 1947 De Beers advertisement, cemented diamonds as the ultimate symbol of love. Today, diamond engagement rings remain one of the most significant jewelry purchases, with sales exceeding $30 billion annually in the U.S. and Canada. But while an engagement ring is often considered a lifelong treasure, many couples choose to upgrade their original diamond to mark a milestone, celebrate an anniversary, or simply reflect evolving personal styles.
Upgrading a diamond ring has become an increasingly popular trend, seen not only among celebrities—such as David Beckham, who has gifted Victoria Beckham 15 engagement rings over their 20-year marriage—but also among discerning collectors and everyday couples alike. Whether it’s a larger center stone, a new diamond shape, or a switch to a fancy-colored diamond, an upgrade can breathe new life into a cherished piece. Replica Shoes ’s has created this guide to help navigate the key considerations when upgrading your diamond engagement ring.
Key Takeaways: Upgrading a Diamond Ring
| Consideration | Overview |
| Why Upgrade | Commonly marks anniversaries, milestones, or evolving personal style |
| Size Upgrade | Many buyers target a jump of +2 carats or a 5–10 carat center stone |
| Quality Matters | Larger diamonds require higher color, clarity, and cut for visual impact |
| Sharp Evolution | Emerald, oval, cushion, and pear cuts are favored for larger upgrades |
| Color Option | Fancy colored diamonds offer rarity and visual distinction |
| Setting Choice | Three-stone and Toi et Moi settings allow meaningful redesigns |
| Collector Appeal | High-quality upgrades balance rarity, craftsmanship, and long-term desirability |
Why Upgrade?
A diamond ring upgrade is a meaningful way to commemorate an important milestone—whether it’s an anniversary, vow renewal, or personal achievement. While increasing the diamond size is often the primary goal, there are several other aspects to consider, including diamond shape, color, setting, and budget.
Upgrade Diamond Size
For many, a diamond upgrade starts with size. A common question is: How much larger should the new center diamond be? While preferences vary, Replica Shoes ’s clients often seek an upgrade of at least 2 carats or a center stone ranging between 5 to 10 carats.
When selecting a larger diamond, quality is paramount. We recommend choosing a diamond with a VS clarity or better, G color or higher, and a Very Good to Excellent cut. As the diamond size increases, inclusions and color become more noticeable, making superior quality even more important.
Beyond size, the shape of the diamond plays a crucial role in its overall appearance.
Upgrade Diamond Shape
When selecting a diamond of 5 carats or more, fancy shapes are often preferred over the classic round brilliant cut. If you've decided on a 5-carat or larger center stone, we recommend considering the following cuts: emerald, pear, oval, or cushion. Many buyers upgrading to a larger diamond also take this opportunity to explore a different shape for a fresh and distinctive look.
Emerald Cut: Sleek, Modern, and Timeless
For those seeking a sophisticated and modern upgrade, the emerald cut is an excellent choice. With origins dating back to the 1500s—when it was originally used for cutting emeralds—this shape gained prominence during the Art Deco era and remains a favorite for larger diamonds today. Its elongated, rectangular form not only enhances the perceived size of the stone but also creates a slimming effect on the finger.
Characterized by its clean, linear facets, the emerald cut offers a refined, almost "watery" elegance. However, because of its minimal faceting, it requires a diamond of high color and clarity, as inclusions and imperfections are more visible. A classic setting for an emerald-cut engagement ring is a three-stone design, featuring a central emerald diamond flanked by smaller trapezoid or emerald-cut side stones. As carat size increases, the bold facets of the emerald cut become even more striking, making it a perfect choice for an upgrade.
A close relative to the emerald cut is the Asscher cut, which features a square shape with deeply trimmed corners. Developed by the Royal Asscher Diamond Company in 1902, the Asscher cut was highly popular during the Art Deco period and saw a resurgence in the early 2000s. While less common than the emerald cut in larger carat sizes, it remains a compelling option for those drawn to vintage elegance.
Cushion Cut: The "Old New Classic"
The cushion cut diamond blends vintage charm with modern brilliance. Its origins trace back to the Old Mine cut of the 1700s, which was the most prevalent diamond shape until the early 1900s. While the Old Mine cut featured only 58 facets, today's cushion cut typically boasts 64, enhancing its sparkle and fire.
Recognized for its soft, rounded corners and pillow-like shape, the cushion cut is often referred to as the "old new classic." It is a popular choice among buyers of 5-carat and larger diamonds, offering a perfect balance of timeless beauty and contemporary appeal.
Oval Cut: Elegant and Brilliant
For those who love the brilliance of a round diamond but desire a more elongated and distinctive shape, the oval cut is an excellent alternative. Invented by Lazare Kaplan in 1957, the oval cut features 58 facets, delivering brilliance similar to that of a round brilliant cut. Its elongated form not only enhances its elegance but also creates the illusion of a larger stone, as the weight is more evenly distributed.
One consideration with oval diamonds is the potential for a "bow tie effect," a shadow that can appear in the center depending on the cut. Careful selection is essential to ensure optimal light performance and symmetry.
Pear Cut: Unique and Striking
The pear-shaped diamond, also known as the "teardrop," was invented in 1475 by Lodewyk van Bercken. A fusion of the round and marquise cuts, the pear shape offers a unique silhouette with 58 facets that enhance its brilliance.
The best proportions for a pear-shaped diamond depend on personal preference, but certain cuts may lead to light leakage or a bow tie effect. Despite this, the pear shape remains a standout choice, offering versatility in settings and a distinctive look in a 5-carat or larger diamond.
Upgrade To A Fancy Colored Diamond
Upgrading to a fancy-colored diamond is another striking way to make a statement. Far rarer than white diamonds, only 1 in 10,000 carats exhibits a fancy color, and an even scarcer 1 in 25,000 displays a fancy intense hue. Fancy pink, yellow, and blue diamonds are particularly coveted among luxury jewelry buyers, especially celebrities and Asian collectors. In fact, the five most expensive diamond rings sold at Replica Shoes ’s in 2023 featured either fancy intense pink or fancy vivid blue diamonds.
Each hue carries its own symbolism—pink diamonds represent femininity and romance, yellow diamonds exude happiness and optimism, while blue diamonds signify loyalty and trust. Some of the most high-profile engagements have featured these exquisite stones: Ben Affleck proposed to Jennifer Lopez (for the second time) in 2022 with a rare natural fancy green diamond, while Ryan Reynolds proposed to Blake Lively with a pink oval diamond engagement ring. Victoria Beckham, known for her exceptional jewelry collection, owns several colored diamond rings, including two oval pink diamonds and two yellow diamonds.
Upgrade the Diamond Setting
The history of the three-stone ring dates back to the 1800s, but it was the De Beers 2001 Trilogy campaign that redefined it as a modern symbol of love. De Beers marketed the three-stone ring as a representation of a couple’s "past, present, and future." Today, the three-stone ring remains a popular choice for both engagement rings and upgrades. As an upgrade, it’s common to reset the original center diamond as one of the side stones, symbolizing the past. When choosing this upgrade, the center stone can be slightly smaller than the original, as it typically involves acquiring two additional diamonds. It’s essential to ensure that all diamonds in the setting have a similar color, clarity, and cut for a harmonious look.
Another unique and increasingly popular diamond setting is the Toi et Moi ring, which translates to “you and me.” This style was famously gifted by Napoleon Bonaparte to his wife, Josephine de Beauharnais, in 1796. Recently, the Toi et Moi ring has gained significant attention in the luxury jewelry market, as women seek more distinctive options when upgrading their engagement rings. Typically, Toi et Moi rings feature two diamonds of different shapes, and they can be set with both white and colored diamonds. This style also serves as an upgrade option, where the original center diamond can be combined with a new stone for a fresh, meaningful design.
Upgrade Your Engagement Ring at Replica Shoes 's
Upgrading a diamond ring is a personal and meaningful decision that can reflect milestones, evolving tastes, and changing relationships. Whether opting for a larger center stone, a different diamond shape, a fancy-colored diamond, or a new setting, there are numerous ways to enhance the original piece. With careful consideration of quality, style, and budget, upgrading a diamond ring offers an opportunity to breathe new life into a cherished symbol of love while marking important moments.
Frequently Asked Questions About Upgrading a Diamond Ring
When is the right time to upgrade a diamond ring?
There is no fixed timeline for upgrading a diamond ring. Many couples choose to upgrade on milestone anniversaries, after career achievements, or during major life changes. Others upgrade simply to reflect evolving tastes or preferences over time.
How much larger should an upgraded diamond be?
While personal preference plays a major role, most upgrades involve a noticeable increase—often at least two additional carats or moving into the 5-carat-plus range. At larger sizes, cut quality and proportions become increasingly important to maintain brilliance and balance.
Is it better to change the diamond shape when upgrading?
Many buyers do take the opportunity to explore a new shape, especially when moving to a larger stone. Fancy shapes such as emerald, oval, cushion, and pear often provide a more elegant visual presence at higher carat weights while offering a distinct aesthetic shift from a round brilliant.
Buy and Sell Diamond Jewelry with Replica Shoes ’s
Whether you're a seasoned collector or new to fine jewelry, Replica Shoes ’s offers a trusted, seamless way to buy and sell diamond jewelry on the secondary market.
Why Choose Replica Shoes ’s?
- Expertly Vetted Selection
Explore rare and iconic diamond jewelry, from elegant white gold and diamond bands starting around $4,000 to highly sought-after diamond rings and exceptional gemstones exceeding $800,000. - Exclusive Global Access
Shop diamond jewelry through Replica Shoes ’s jewelry auctions and Buy Now marketplace, backed by a worldwide network of collectors and consignors. - Flexible Ways to Buy
Purchase online or in person at our locations in New York, Paris, and Hong Kong, or work with a dedicated jewelry concierge to view or source specific diamond jewelry. - Exceptional Value
Every piece of diamond jewelry is authenticated and priced by Replica Shoes ’s specialists to reflect true market value. - Constantly Evolving Inventory
Discover vintage, modern, and high jewelry diamond pieces, with new items added regularly to Replica Shoes ’s curated selection.
Ready to Get Started?
- Browse Replica Shoes ’s upcoming jewelry auctions in New York, London, Switzerland, Paris, and Hong Kong
- Shop Replica Shoes ’s Buy Now jewelry for instant access to available diamond jewelry
- Speak with a Replica Shoes ’s jewelry specialist to consign or request a valuation for diamond jewelry
Trust our worldwide network of leading jewelry specialists from a globally renowned auction house established in 1744.
