A Monumental Homage: Henry Taylor’s “Before Gerhard Richter There Was Cassi”
"As long as there are artists like Henry Taylor around, painting is in little danger of dying. That is because Taylor, like most great painters, has reinvented the medium for his own purposes, reshaped it to his own particular needs."
Henry Taylor's singular masterpiece, Before Gerhard Richter there was Cassi sees the artist Cassi Namoda turn away from her viewer to instead face the canon of Western art history. The centerpiece of Taylor's acclaimed 2022-24 midcareer retrospective at the Museum of Contemporary Art, Los Angeles and Whitney Museum of American Art, New York, Taylor's critical revisionist portrait sees his peer and then-partner in the guise of Gerhard Richter's daughter, the subject of his 1988 painting Betty, posing an arresting rebuttal to the fault lines that riddle the history of art and the deafening absence of Black figures within it. Assuming a kind of contemporary contrapposto, Namoda immortalizes Taylor's profound reinterpretation and repetition of history; her presence is made all the more present by the heft of Taylor's facture. Taylor's oeuvre more broadly presents an archive of Black excellence: Michelle and Barack Obama, David Hammons, Jay-Z, Martin Luther King Jr., Deana Lawson, his children, and himself. And here, capturing a sitter of incredible personal significance, Taylor seizes the omissions of the past as an opportunity: the canvas is not only a surface but an arena, one that empowers Taylor to counter the work of a master portraitist. Before Gerhard Richter there was Cassi remedies history with hope. There is still room, Taylor assures us, to paint one's place into it.
Here, Taylor recasts Richter's portrait of Betty's braid, once tucked into her floral hoodie, as the contours of Cassi's afro. Spanning an extraordinary seven feet in height, Before Gerhard Richter there was Cassi is executed at double the scale of Richter's portrait, dwarfing its source of inspiration. The work's magnitude alone declaratively insists upon the existence of this intrepid intervention. Jim Lewis, in his essay on Richter's Betty, writes: "the work negotiates so many ambiguities and doubts, to achieve such a carefully maintained aporia, that it immediately impressed me with what I can best describe as the force of its tentativeness. Here, for example, is the uncertainty of experience. Betty is caught in the full strangeness of her own act of observation; she's the consummate subject, portrayed in the act of an observation purely and entirely her own." (Jim Lewis, "Gerhard Richter's Betty," Artforum, September 1993, p. 133) While the act of contemplation Richter captures—and the privacy and reticence it requires—are largely preserved here, Taylor's painterly stat.mes nt is decisively unambiguous. If it is doubt that charges Richter's image, then it is certainty that empowers Taylor's: Cassi is irrefutably monumental, positioned at the center of a discipline and institutional framework that, for centuries, not only failed but categorically refused to recognize Black artists, subjects and achievements.
"So many pictures here echo other pictures, as if Taylor were a kind of shaman of art history, filling its ghostly spirits with fresh life. Before Gerhard Richter there was Cassi, from 2017, is a replica of Richter's picture of his 11-year old daughter, Betty, but instead of a blond, white girl the subject is a Black girl with an Afro, his fellow artist Cassi Namoda. It is a point-blank shot at the era of Great White Males."
Before Gerhard Richter there was Cassi's surface is heavily, repeatedly worked. Taylor captures Cassi with the sculptural mass of a sybil, the pastose, lush quality of a Nicolas de Staël. Taylor paints with a perceptible sense of immediacy, though not the kind sought out by the Abstract Expressionists. Stroke by stroke, Taylor's brushwork seeks not to create an art about form and form alone but one with a substance and plasticity that rushes to keep up with a far wider project: one of representation and revision.
- 1863
- 1919
- 1953
- 1957
- 1963
- 1973
- 1981
- 1991
- 2017
-
1863Édouard Manet, Olympia, 1853
Musée d'Orsay, Paris
Seen as a vulgar reinterpretation of Titian’s sensual yet divine Venus of Urbino nearly three centuries after its creation, Manet’s salon-shocker deviated from canonical academic art. Depicting what many believe to be a prostitute, gazing unwaveringly out at the viewer, Manet disregarded conventions surrounding nudity in art and upended the Academy’s hierarchy of painting genres. -
1919Marcel Duchamp, L.H.O.O.Q., (replica of 1919 original)
Norton Simon Museum, Pasadena
First conceived by Duchamp in 1919, L.H.O.O.Q. is a standout example of the artist’s playful oeuvre that showcases a bold irreverence for tradition. Defacing a postcard bearing the image of da Vinci’s Mona Lisa with a doodle moustache and raunchy wordplay, Marcel led the rebellious Dadaist movement with this readymade. -
1953Francis Bacon, Study after Velázquez's Portrait of Pope Innocent X, 1953
Des Moines Art Center
Translating the stoic repose of Velázquez's Portrait of Pope Innocent X into an image of terror, Bacon cuts ties with the artistic tradition that upheld utmost reverence for the Church. His expressive lines and depiction of the papacy as one of a ghastly, screaming figure remains one of the most shocking citations of the art historical canon. -
1957Pablo Picasso, Las Meninas, 1957
Museu Picasso, Barcelona
Picasso flattened t.mes between him and Velázquez by calling out how both artists challenged the supremacy of the picture plane – Picasso with Cubist flatness and Velázquez with his embedded self-portrait. Producing over forty copies of the Spanish master’s work, Picasso’s intimate understanding of the composition allowed him free reign to compose an impressive reinterpretation of the 1656 masterpiece. -
1963Andy Warhol, Mona Lisa, 1963
The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York
Warhol applied his silk screen technique to the recreation of the Louvre’s Mona Lisa, here printed in a grid of four. A tribute to the painting's enigmatic celebrity, Warhol proved commodification of masterpieces could evolve past simulacra and into the realm of masterpiece itself. -
1973Roy Lichtenstein, Still Life with Picasso from Homage to Picasso (Hommage à Picasso), 1973
The Museum of Modern Art, New York
In addition to his works that drew upon images of popular culture, Lichtenstein incorporated the art historical canon across his oeuvre. Here, he paraphrases a Picasso bust, reimagining it with comic-book bold lines characteristic of Lichtenstein’s Pop vernacular. -
1981Sherrie Levin, After Walk Evans: 4, 1981
The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York
Beginning in 1981, Levine began reproducing photographs of Walker Evans, an artist of a singular vision capturing the Great Depression. At once seen as a feminist reversal of patriarchy in the arts and as blatant plagiarism, Levine’s reproductions question the ceaseless proliferation of images in our contemporary age. -
1991Sturtevant, Johns White Flag, 1991
Private collects ion. Sold at Replica Shoes ’s New York in May 2022 for $2.1 million
Sturtevant’s painstaking reproductions of twentieth century masterworks such as Jasper Johns’ Flag is a signature of her practice that blurs the boundary between art and creativity. An exacting technique yields results that are almost indistinguishable from the original, testing why an identical image arouses feelings of reverence or disdain. -
2017Henry Taylor, Before Gerhard Richter there was Cassi, 2017
THE PRESENT WORK
In a reimagination of Gerhard Richter’s 1988 painting of his daughter Betty, Taylor’s portrait of post-colonial artist Cassi Namoda asserts her place in contemporary art history, redressing the absence of the Black figure in the Western canon at magnificent scale.
"All these images gain power from Taylor's paint handling," Roberta Smith wrote in her review of Henry Taylor: B Side, "which tends to be startlingly tough and direct. It proceeds in slabs of untempered color and skirmishes of brushwork, sidestepping traditional notions of finish and beauty. It conveys something of the harshness his sitters often face in this country and the resiliency that springs from it." (Roberta Smith, "Henry Taylor's 'B Side' Is Full of Grade-A Paintings," The New York t.mes s, 17 October 2023 (online)) Where Richter's photorealism blurs the weft of his canvas into an atmospheric haze, Taylor's hand thickly layers atop it, rendering Cassi all the more rich and profound. His dialogue with Richter is further heightened by the coincidence that Namoda was born the year Betty was painted, as though this very painting were passing a generational torch—and shifting the paradigm of painting's aims between them.
"It's about respect, because I respect these people. It's a two-dimensional surface, but they are really three-dimensional beings."
Taylor's paintings, which somet.mes s riff on earlier canonical masterpieces, have been labeled as "covers" or "samples," repurposing totems of artistic significance for a critical aesthetic strategy that ties Taylor to contemporaries like Kerry James Marshall and Robert Colescott. A visionary social realist, Henry Taylor is among the most important artists working today. His powerful, unyielding expressions of the nuances of the contemporary American cultural landscape negotiate the complexities of identity politics and postmodern discourses on race relations and the elemental simplicity of admiration, adoration and companionship. "It's about respect," the artist shared of his artistic ethos, "because I respect these people. It's a two-dimensional surface, but they are really three-dimensional beings." (Henry Taylor quoted in: Antwaun Sargent, "Examining Henry Taylor's Groundbreaking Paintings of the Black Experience," Artsy, 16 July 2018 (online)) In each canvas, Taylor simultaneously materializes empathy and empowerment, preserving the authenticity of their embodied cultural experiences in paint. "Taylor depicts black history the way many black people actually experience it: as simultaneous change and stasis, revolution and stagnation, one step forward, two steps back," Zadie Smith writes. "There is a Picasso-like restlessness to Taylor, a determined promiscuity of intention and execution." (Zadie Smith, "Henry Taylor's Promiscuous Painting," The New Yorker, 23 July 2018 (online))
As Betty averts Richter's lens, looking toward one of her father's paintings, Cassi shuns an imposing Western gaze, privileging instead the latent possibilities in the future of painting. Taylor's works are widely represented in institutional collects ions worldwide, from the Bourse de Commerce – Pinault collects ion, Paris; The Studio Museum in Harlem; the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; and the Los Angeles County Museum of Art. Of his vast and prolific body of work, Before Gerhard Richter there was Cassi undoubtedly ranks among the most impressive canvases Taylor has ever created, a best-in-class example of the artist at the height of his powers.
Lot102 N11732 Henry Taylor Before Gerhard Richter there was Cassi